Skip to content

National PB Cookie Day with the BEST PB Cookies

Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies

Peanut butter chocolate star cookies disappear quicker than any others!

Besides the chocolate chip cookies, the recipe I can remember always being my favorite was the peanut butter blossoms or peanut butter chocolate star cookies.  And even to this day, I can’t eat just one.  I have to have at least 2 or 3 every time that my hand goes into the proverbial cookie jar.  I’m telling you, these cookies disappear quicker than any others!  They are so good.  Unfortunately, I normally only make them around the holidays.  But I’ve been trying to make them more often since everyone in my house likes them.  I also use them to bribe my brother to come do odd jobs for me.  What can I say, he’s cheap labor (but very talented)!

He’s always so good to come help me out with the little jobs around the house that my husband or I aren’t talented enough to accomplish.  And always willing to help me out with little tasks when they come to visit.  It’s kind of a running joke that he doesn’t come to the house without his toolbox because I always have something for him to do when he’s there.  I’m hoping to get him to help me with new deck railings sometime this summer but he’s telling me that it might cost me more than just a plate or two of cookies for a job like that!  But when all else fails, I offer up babysitting duty for him and his wife to get a weekend getaway.  That usually does the job!  hehe

Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies

I know you can see a lot of different looking peanut butter blossoms.  I like mine to have a little more cookie and I like them a little thicker.  But to start, they are a pretty basic peanut butter cookie recipe.  You do need to spend a little extra time on them by rolling them each into balls and then rolling them in sugar.  You need to carefully place the tray in the oven so the peanut butter dough balls don’t roll all to one side.  And yes, I’m speaking from experience there.  LOL

After the cookies have baked for a little bit and are starting to crack on the top, you take them out of the oven long enough to put a chocolate star in the middle and press it down just a little.  Some people use chocolate kisses but I never wanted to spend all that time unwrapping each kiss.  I’d probably have to buy more kisses before I got them all unwrapped.  Unwrap one, eat one, unwrap one, put in the pile for cookies, unwrap one, eat one, you get the idea?!?  Chocolate stars just all come in one bag and I can eat just a couple without impacting the cookie making too much.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies

But I will tell you that if you’re planning on making these cookies around Christmas time, you might want to get stars early!  In the past, I’ve had to go to several stores to find the stars during the holiday season because this recipe is obviously so popular.  Now, I just keep a bag in the fridge most of the time.  Then I have them handy for bribery or a special treat for the family.

After you’ve put the stars on the cookies, stick them back in the oven for two minutes.  Enough time to let the stars or kisses melt.   Once they’ve come out, I let them sit up for a few minutes on the cookie sheet and transfer them to foil to cool.  They are the very best out of the oven when the cookie is still really soft and the chocolate is melted.  But truth be told, I’ll eat them anytime!

Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies

The cookie is nice and chewy and you get a little bite of chocolate with it.  I think everyone has a different way of eating them.  Some people eat the chocolate star first and then the cookie part.  Then there’s the people that eat around the chocolate and then eat the chocolate last.  People like me eat half the cookie part and then the chocolate. After that, then finish up with the rest of the cookie part.  And some take the perfect bite of cookie with a little chocolate.

However you think you’d eat them, you really need to eat them!  Well, make them first and then eat them!  They are so good and not just for holidays anymore!

TTYL!  Lori

Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies
Print Recipe
Servings Prep Time
3.5 dozen 20 minutes
Cook Time
7-9 minutes
Servings Prep Time
3.5 dozen 20 minutes
Cook Time
7-9 minutes
Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies
Print Recipe
Servings Prep Time
3.5 dozen 20 minutes
Cook Time
7-9 minutes
Servings Prep Time
3.5 dozen 20 minutes
Cook Time
7-9 minutes
Ingredients
Servings: dozen
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
  2. Cream butter, peanut butter, and sugars. Add egg and vanilla and mix well.
  3. Add dry ingredients until well combined.
  4. Scoop dough into balls and roll until smooth. Then roll in sugar and place evenly on baking sheet.
  5. Bake for 7-9 minutes. Remove from oven. Press chocolate stars into each cookie and place back in the oven for 1 minute.
  6. Let cool for a few minutes on the cookie sheet and then move the cookies to a sheet of foil.
Recipe Notes
  • If you're making the cookies to send to someone, try placing the stars into the cookies upside down.  This creates a more level stacking surface for sending.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Star Cookies

Get Free Email Updates!

Signup now and receive an email once I publish new content.

Your privay is important to me. I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Share this post Facebooktwittergoogle_pluspinterestFacebooktwittergoogle_pluspinterest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top